Rodriguez beats Lucas to the screen

Robert Rodriguez’s comic book film Sin City
will be the first film to be shot in 4:4:4 HD. It managed to beat George Lucas’ last installment of Star Wars.

jessica alba
bruce willis

Who is Robert Rodriguez ?


He is one of the few successful Indie film makers who not only have made it big in Hollywood, but have done so with an unique style of film making. The others include Quentin Tarantino (Pulp Fiction, Kill Bills), Steven Sodenberg (Oceans 11 , Erin Brokowitch, Traffic). These film makers started from zero, and based on pure talent commanded a cult following among fans. Rodriguez as a 23 year old, made a ultra low budget mexican gangbang flick “El Mariachi” with just $7,000. The movie was so well done that it was picked up by a Major studio and made pots of money. Rodriguez then followed up with Desperado and stylishly shot “Once Upon a time in Mexico”. He also did the kids flick “Spy Kids”.

Rodriguez successfully proved that he can do everything himself and not rely neither on Hollywood machinery nor its mammoth unions (WGA and DGA – he resigned from both places) to be successful. He completes his movies in his ‘Garage’ – shoots, edits, composes out of his HOME. But does it with such flair that it is indistinguishable from big budget movies. When budgets were soaring north of $100mil, he made desperado under $7mil. Infact, all his movies are mounted on flashy glossy frames, but is actually D-I-Y stuff.

He has denounced film films and is a staunch supporter of digital film making. He has been shooting digital since 2000.

So why is SIN CITY a path breaker ?

Well, this is the first film to be done in 4:4:4 space. It is full-bandwidth RGB – the maximum visual data you can get out of a scene. It is very hard to edit and produce a feature using existing technologies in 4:4:4. Lucas ‘ upcoming Star Wars is done on 4:4:4. Sin City beat it by about a month.

Ok back to 4:4:4. Consumer digital video cameras typically use a 4:1:1 format. SD (standard definition) cameras use a 4:2:2 format. HD cameras can use 4:2:2, or a 4:2:0 format based on “spatial” samples of 2×2-pixel squares. So 4:4:4 is the highest possible source sample you can get out of a camera. Theoretically its even better or on par with Film. But being an all digital signal, it has so many advantages over film.

One of the key features is chroma-keying. Rodriguez being a home-based film maker has a lot of computer generated shots. He had live actors acting in front of Green screens totally detached from everything else seen on screen – they talk to air, they react to air, even kiss air – but when fully composited they might as well be talking to a 3 headed alien under Planet Neboolah’s purple acidic ocean with firespitting sea ants in the background. These green screens have been used for a long time – but being all digital just makes it easier. ‘Skycaptain and the world of Tomorrow’ was the first film which was done totally using chroma keying (and the chinese fantasy movie Casshern). So 4:4:4 offers maximum data to do seamless chroma keying.

This is one movie I can’t wait to watch. Its releasing on April 1 – hope it doesn’t turn out to be an April fools movie.

Another interesting name attached to ‘Sin City’ is Quentin Tarantino. QT was paid $1 to direct a small segment in the climax. Maybe that’s Roberts way of getting back at QT for paying him $1 to compose musical score for ‘Kill Bill2′. No, actually they are good buddies and even directed an indie hit ‘Four Rooms’ (1995) together. Then they collaborated in mexican vampire movie ‘From Dusk till Dawn’ (1996).

Rodriguez is also partially responsible for energizing the careers of Antonio Banderas, Salma Hayek and George Clooney.

JVC enters with a bang

WEVA site broke the news today morning (and was promptly taken down within hours) about the upcoming JVC HD cam. It offered a rare glimpse into what JVC has in store.

Its 24p proHDV cam (since HDV specs doesnt include 24p, JVC calls it proHDV)

If you notice it looks like it has a 1/3″ lens mount. Hmmm…. how many 1/3″ lenses have you seen ? For what its worth, they also said there is a 1/2″ adapter available. Thats much better.

Some words from the actual premature press release:

“In addition to providing superior quality HD recording in the 24p format, the GY-HD100U can output an uncompressed 720/P60 HD signal. This is ideal for live broadcasting, remote news and POV applications. A third party HDSDI converter can provide the full resolution uncompressed signal to an array of systems with no signal delay.”

Full resolution! – that elusive 4:2:2 comes to pro-sumer level! Or it can just mean another clichéd marketing jargon like ‘Ultimate Home Theater’ or ‘Full Digital

And it has a interchangable lens system! I always loved that flexiblity. Except Canon XL2, all pro-sumer camera’s dont have it. This includes DVX100, upcoming HDX100, FX1 and Z1u

Now I am sure this will give the just announced Panasonic HDX 100 a run for its money.

And, yes, if competitively priced – these two cams will kill Sony’s Z1u even before it left the hospital. Sad, I always loved a Sony. Having said that outside US Sony still commands respect among Indie filmmakers.

HD formats

24p Cameras:

Currently there are 2 cameras which does 24p in prosumer marker:

Canon XL2

Panasonic DVX100A.

Why is 24p important ?

Before we get into that. Have u noticed any difference between your 6’o clock news in TV and a DVD movie ? 6’o clock news is crisp bright and screams video video – but DVD movie is soft and dramatic. The main reason being TV afternoon dramas, News are all shot at 60i, that is 60 interlaced video. That is 60 fields per second. But a movie is shot at 24 frames per second. Also, movie is shot in a progressive mode, while 60i is shot in interlace mode. Progressive captures the entire scene in one instant. But interlace captures 30 fields in one second, and captures the next 30 fields in the next second. Mixes them both to produce a 60 field per second.

Let take an example of a car moving, and examine how the scene will look different when shot in both formats. Progressive will capture each scene as one frame, while interlace captures half frame in one second, then the car would have moved a bit in the next second where it captures the next frame. Of course, it will not to explicitly visible to an ordinary eye – but if you PAUSE the interlaced footage you will see all the edges jagged.

So where does 24p come in here ?
Quite simply put – 24p motion closely emulates the ‘feel’ of film. So you can fool your audience into thinking that you used a 35mm film camera to shoot. Smooth pleasing motion with the correct amount of motion blur. This will take the digital (read artificial) feel out of the camera.

HDV Cameras: Note, this is one of the variants of High Def format. There are many. Sony, Canon and JVC support HDV format, Panasonic has its own HD format called DVCPROHD. HDV is high definition DV. Digital Video is 720×480 pixels (4:3 ratio like TV), HDV is 1440×1080 pixels (16:9 ratio like Movies). Another major point is, HDV doesn’t not shoot 24p.

Sony is the first one to shake up the broadcast industry to produce a camera for a measly $3,500 with Sony HDR-FX1. Again, Sony followed it up with Sony HVR-Z1U for $4,999. The main difference between these two cameras are not image quality, but more pro features. Z1u has XLR inputs (external mic) and is NTSC/PAL switchable (60i/50i)

HDV currently is awkward to edit. But as with anything in the computer world things change very fast. Also these are not 24p cameras.

HDV vs DVCPROHD

HDV is a consumer format, based on interframe compression. It takes a bunch of pictures (15) and compresses them together. Technically it is prone to drop-outs on Tape, where 15 frames just disappear leading to a frozen .5 seconds or jerk. But solid state storage could potentially solve this.

DVCPROHD is based on intraframe compression. So it compresses each frame, and is independent of the frame before and after the current frame.

HDV is 4:2:0 and DVCPROHD is 4:2:2 which leades to better color sampling.

HDV is 25mps data while DVCPROHD can be as high as 100mps.

HDV can be recorded into orinary MiniDV tapes, while DVCPROHD needs special tapes or P2 solid state cards.

Upcoming 24p cameras:
Panasonic HDX-100 about $6,999 – $9,999 will shoot in many flavors. Standard DV (DVCPRO25), Digi-beta (DVCPRO50) and DVCPROHD (High Def). This will also sport a solid state storage device (like compact flash in dSLR)

JVC GY-HD100 about $6,999 – $9,999 will have interchangeable lenses and shoot a variant of HDV called ProHD. ProHD is a hacked HDV format which does a 24p. So you get best of both worlds. HDV and 24p. Unique

5 Second Movie

Today I shot and directed my first “movie”! It was 5 seconds long. WTF?! 5 seconds ?? Ok a little flashback.

Cadillac has built this new car which goes from 0-60mph in 5 seconds. So someone in their Marketing dept thot it might be a cool idea to have a 5 second movie contest to underline the fact.

So, My movie was shot to showcase the speed of the new cadillac car. Unfortunately, I wasnt able to spend a whole lot of time on making it. As the deadline was tomorrow.

I had a simple idea – then I played around with Adobe Aftereffects till I got the timings right. I was satisified with it, it turned out good given the time I spent on it. It was a good experience of telling a tale with no visuals, and using audience’s contextual continuity to decipher the message of my film.

Phew! Did I sound complex enuf ? Complex and twisted logic is the hallmark of indie filmmakers, and I dont want to be the odd one out ;)

ok, for those interested in seeing it – here is the link

‘Can we go for a ride?’ – 5 second movie (Needs Quicktime)

HD for the rest of us

Digital Moviemaking has finally arrived!

I can see you rolling your eyes…

Yeah, yeah, they said the same in 1996 when Sony released VX1000, they said that when 3CDD camcoders hit the shelves. They keep saying the same thing over and over that it becomes the story of the ‘Crying Wolf’. There should be some audit for Marketing Fluff.

Ok, now that I have released my big beef with the overused cliche’s. Here is the big news!

Digital Moviemaking has finally arrived!

Why ? Because a new HDV camcoder has been released Sony FX1 ($3299) and its big brother Sony Z1u ($4999). This is the first time a High Definition camera has been released which is below the magic pro-sumer mark of $5,000. To put this in prespective, it was $40,000 an year back, and $100,000 2 years back.

Can it become $999 over the next few years ? Quite possibly, but you would lose out on grabing this when it is within arms reach and lose over 2 years of shooting/learning time.

So, should we go out and buy a Fx1 or Z1u – the answer is ‘NO’

Wait till April 18, 2005 if you can. That is when another big daddy Panasonic is going to announce its answer to Sony’s Fx1/Z1u. Why April 18, you might ask – that is when NAB happens in Las Vegas, NV. NAB is broadcast industry’s biggest and baddest annual conference.

There are rumors of HDX100, the DVCPRO-HD avatar of the cult favourite DVX100. This year things are hotting up for a budding indie moviemaker.

Like the internet arrived in 1996 to the masses, 2005 looks like the year when moviemaking arrives to the masses.