Panasonic HVX200 becomes the first camera under $100,000 to record high-definition 1080/24p. The ONLY other camera is Sony’s CineAlta, a $100,000 camera which, Lucas and Rodriguez used in ‘Star Wars II’ and ‘Once upon a time in Mexico’. They both use Sony exclusvely

Also this $5995 camera does what a $65,000 Varicam does - variable frame rates! It can shoot any framerate from 4 to 60fps!.

Yes it is a wonderboy cam - it does all ‘good’ flavors of HD without its nasty after effects.

What does that mean ?
HD as HDV is popularly called, is a horrible format. Wait, before you flame me, hear it out. HDV is a consumer format, plain and simple. It has low color sampling (4:2:0) , high compressions. Also HDV specs dont have the indie favorite 24p recording. So smarter companies (read JVC, Panasonic) take the HDV standard and customize it.

JVC customized HDV as ProHDV - it made two simple changes - added 24p and relaxed the compression algorithms. Instead of compressing a group of 15 frames, it grouped only 6. But Panasonic went further and threw out interframe compression altogether and compressed each frame individually in its DVCPRO-HD format. Also it doubled color sampling from 4:2:0 it made it 4:2:2.

JVC and Panasonic has released their respective versions now. Its called HD100 and AG-HVX200

  Panasonic AG-HVX200 JVC HD-100 Sony Z1u Winner
Shoots in

1080/60i
1080/30p
1080/24p

720/60p
720/30p
720/24p

720/30p
720/24p
1080/50i/60i Clearly Pana
Progressive ? Yes Yes No, Interlaced JVC & Pana
Real 24p ? Yes Yes NO! JVC & Pana
Default Lens 13x 16x interchangeable   Clearly JVC
Lens Fixed Real HD Manual Lens Fixed Clearly JVC
HD Flavor DVCHD-PRO PROHDV HDV Clearly Pana
Color Sampling 4:2:2 4:2:0 4:2:0 Clearly Pana
Recording P2 Media & HDD MiniDV Tape, HDD MiniDV JVC & Pana
Shutter Variable! (4-60fps)     Clearly Pana
Audio Less compressed Compressed Compressed Panasonic
Compression Within 1 frame With group of 6 frames Group of 15 frames Clearly Pana
Form Handycam Should Mount Handycam JVC
Looks Non Pro Real Pro looks Looks cool JVC
Positives

720 & 1080
4:2:2 color
Variable Shutter
Slow motion
Green Screening

Interchangeable HD Lens
More Resolution
Records to Tape

Shoots both NTSC/PAL  
Negatives

Fixed Lens
P2 Media Expensive (8gb $2000)

HDV Compression
no 1080
4:2:0 Color

No 24p
No Progressive
15 frame compression
4:2:0 Color

 
Price $5995 - Available Oct $6295 - Available June $5949 - Now!  
   

Can it get any better than this ?

Yes, how about a 4:4:4 HD interchangeable 35mm lens camera !! - enter DRAKE… more details on it when it becomes available


4 Responses to “Pana and JVC unwrapped”  

  1. 1 Ramji

    That was cool. Nice comparison. The JVC looks real pro. Keep posting more articles on this 24p topic. Very informative.

  2. 2 Martin

    It seems that Panasonic is the obvious winner of this competition.
    But wil Canon charge $8999 for their XL H1? To me that seems to be asking for trouble.

  3. 3 Chris

    All digital audio is compressed. DVCPRO HD audio is compressed. HDV is more compressed.

  4. 4 ramz

    thanks Chris

Leave a Reply



visitor stats