Pana and JVC unwrapped
Panasonic HVX200 becomes the first camera under $100,000 to record high-definition 1080/24p. The ONLY other camera is Sony’s CineAlta, a $100,000 camera which, Lucas and Rodriguez used in ‘Star Wars II’ and ‘Once upon a time in Mexico’. They both use Sony exclusvely
Also this $5995 camera does what a $65,000 Varicam does - variable frame rates! It can shoot any framerate from 4 to 60fps!.
Yes it is a wonderboy cam - it does all ‘good’ flavors of HD without its nasty after effects.
What does that mean ?
HD as HDV is popularly called, is a horrible format. Wait, before you flame me, hear it out. HDV is a consumer format, plain and simple. It has low color sampling (4:2:0) , high compressions. Also HDV specs dont have the indie favorite 24p recording. So smarter companies (read JVC, Panasonic) take the HDV standard and customize it.
JVC customized HDV as ProHDV - it made two simple changes - added 24p and relaxed the compression algorithms. Instead of compressing a group of 15 frames, it grouped only 6. But Panasonic went further and threw out interframe compression altogether and compressed each frame individually in its DVCPRO-HD format. Also it doubled color sampling from 4:2:0 it made it 4:2:2.
JVC and Panasonic has released their respective versions now. Its called HD100 and AG-HVX200
| Panasonic AG-HVX200 | JVC HD-100 | Sony Z1u | Winner | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Shoots in |
1080/60i 720/60p |
720/30p 720/24p |
1080/50i/60i | Clearly Pana |
| Progressive ? | Yes | Yes | No, Interlaced | JVC & Pana |
| Real 24p ? | Yes | Yes | NO! | JVC & Pana |
| Default Lens | 13x | 16x interchangeable | Clearly JVC | |
| Lens | Fixed | Real HD Manual Lens | Fixed | Clearly JVC |
| HD Flavor | DVCHD-PRO | PROHDV | HDV | Clearly Pana |
| Color Sampling | 4:2:2 | 4:2:0 | 4:2:0 | Clearly Pana |
| Recording | P2 Media & HDD | MiniDV Tape, HDD | MiniDV | JVC & Pana |
| Shutter | Variable! (4-60fps) | Clearly Pana | ||
| Audio | Less compressed | Compressed | Compressed | Panasonic |
| Compression | Within 1 frame | With group of 6 frames | Group of 15 frames | Clearly Pana |
| Form | Handycam | Should Mount | Handycam | JVC |
| Looks | Non Pro | Real Pro looks | Looks cool | JVC |
| Positives |
720 & 1080 |
Interchangeable HD Lens |
Shoots both NTSC/PAL | |
| Negatives |
Fixed Lens |
HDV Compression |
No 24p |
|
| Price | $5995 - Available Oct | $6295 - Available June | $5949 - Now! | |
![]() |
![]() |
![]() |
Can it get any better than this ?
Yes, how about a 4:4:4 HD interchangeable 35mm lens camera !! - enter DRAKE… more details on it when it becomes available




That was cool. Nice comparison. The JVC looks real pro. Keep posting more articles on this 24p topic. Very informative.
It seems that Panasonic is the obvious winner of this competition.
But wil Canon charge $8999 for their XL H1? To me that seems to be asking for trouble.
All digital audio is compressed. DVCPRO HD audio is compressed. HDV is more compressed.
thanks Chris